Coffee shops

Stonykill Coffee & Records

4.9 30 reviews Closed 36 Main St Fl. 2, Chatham, NY 12037, United States

Discover this place

Stonykill Coffee & Records is a gem tucked away at 36 Main St., Chatham, NY, known for its vibrant community atmosphere and passion for quality coffee. Locals rave about the exceptional brews, with many praising Anthony, the owner and barista, for his expertise and friendly demeanor. Patrons describe the ambiance as funky and welcoming, perfect for savoring a cup of the best espresso in Chatham while surrounded by vinyl records and vintage books.

Reviewers highlight unique drink options, including a Turmeric Latte and fun latte variations that cater to both coffee aficionados and those seeking a non-caffeinated experience. Stonykill also offers delicious pastries that pair beautifully with their outstanding coffee. The inviting space, complete with comfortable seating and even a pool table, encourages guests to linger and engage in lively conversation.

Overall, Stonykill Coffee & Records stands out not just for its thoughtfully crafted beverages, but for creating a genuine community hub. It’s a place to relax, enjoy great music, and connect with neighbors—something that residents and visitors alike deeply appreciate. This coffee shop is a labor of love, exemplifying passion and attention to detail that makes it a must-visit spot in Chatham.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery

Highlights

Fast service
Great coffee
Great tea selection
Live performances

Popular for

Solo dining

Amenities

Bar onsite
Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy
Trendy

Crowd

Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Stonykill Coffee & Records before visiting.

Reviews for Stonykill Coffee & Records

4.9

30 reviews

100%

Review highlights

Based on 30 reviews

Stonykill Coffee & Records is widely praised for its exceptional coffee offerings, with many customers highlighting expertly crafted espresso and specialty drinks. The establishment’s unique combination of a cozy coffee shop and an eclectic record store creates a welcoming and vibrant atmosphere that fosters community connections. Patrons appreciate the friendly and personable service, particularly the warm engagement from the owner and staff. The inviting ambiance, complete with vintage records, books, and additional amenities like a pool table, contributes to its charm. Feedback consistently notes the quality of both the beverages and the curated environment, making it a standout destination in Chatham for coffee enthusiasts and culture seekers alike.

Trap

Sep 18, 2025

As a local, this is my go to place for great coffee, great conversation, maybe picking up one of the guitars hanging on the rack to noodle, or looking out the window onto Main Street to critique people’s parallel parking skills or lack thereof. Anthony is a great guy and a fantastic Barista. If the coffee wasn’t happening I wouldn’t be there. He’s smart to have a few non caffeinated drinks as well like a Turmeric Latte or a Citron Chaud, pardon my French, teas and other drinks. Go for the coffee and stay for the records and company.

Makeda Rose

Aug 06, 2025

Owner is very sweet! And the coffee shop has a welcoming funky vibe~ Best espresso in Chatham! -

Serena Roth

Jul 29, 2025

Beautiful space with outstanding coffee and pastries, and a super cool record shop area. The owner is amazing and friendly, and the vibes are perfect. We can’t wait to come back.

APS *

Jul 13, 2025

So great to finally have specialty coffee in the area. We are really into coffee and enjoyed the espresso, Aeropress, and unique and fun options for lattes and cortados. The service food not have been better. We also bought a vintage record. Beautiful space and good seating. We also had some nice biscotti.

Will Pflaum

Jul 12, 2025

Anthony has done the world a great favor by creating this wonderful community space. The best possible coffee I have ever had is another plus. Anthony is an asset to Columbia County and Chatham by creating this unique and wonderful space. The pool table, the used books, the LPs, hand grounded beans... There is no place like it. Large cities wish they had a community hangout this legit. Anthony did this as a labor of love as a recoverying academic and I bow down and praise him and this A double plus fantastic place to chat with neighbors and other stuff.

Andrew DiMicelli

Jul 03, 2025

It’s upstairs, I got confused at first when I saw the bar below it. Best machiattio I’ve ever had, they use Gimme Coffee which is amazing, and really cool place overall, it’s like a mini record store with seating and fantastic coffee

Jonathan Lees

Jul 03, 2025

The vibes are immaculate. A second floor cafe with seating perched in front of the window overlooking Main Street. An eclectic mix of records, patrons, and a nice staff plus one of the coolest coffee creations I’ve tasted. Can’t wait to go back.

Luxia Jule

Jun 28, 2025

An intimate space that transitions from a small record section to open seating around a cafe. The barista was friendly, there was a small selection of pastries like scones and croissants and a seasonal list of drinks. Overall a decent stop